Política de revisión por pares y procedimiento de toma de decisiones editoriales
Scope and review model
All scholarly articles, including original research, reviews, theoretical and methodological papers, case studies and research notes, undergo double-anonymous peer review before acceptance. Authors’ identities are unknown for reviewers and reviewers’ identities are unknown from authors; editors know both. Each article requires at least two substantive reports from independent external reviewers. Preliminary editorial screening does not replace these reports. Authors receive anonymized substantive reports.
Submission and preliminary assessment
Authors submit through the journal’s Open Journal Systems (OJS) platform or sending the manuscript via email, providing a separate title page, anonymised manuscript and supporting files. Required declarations address originality, exclusive submission, authorship, competing interests, ethics and AI use. Ethics approval or documented exemption, consent and protection of participant information are required where applicable. Prior dissemination must be disclosed for editorial assessment.
The editor checks scope, completeness, contribution, methodological suitability, reporting quality and ethical documentation. The editor may request technical corrections or reject a submission without external review for being outside scope or having fundamental scholarly or ethical deficiencies. Authors receive the reasons and details of their manuscript rejection or correction. Plagiarism scores and AI-detection outputs are screening signals, not proof of misconduct or automatic rejection thresholds; editors assess the evidence and seek explanations where appropriate. The results of similarity check and AI detection are sent to the reviewers.
Reviewer selection and ethical responsibilities
The editor in Chief, with editor and the members of Editorial Board verify reviewers’ identities, qualifications and expertise. Reviewers must be external to the editorial board; decision-making editors do not count as the two external reviewers. Current institutional colleagues, close collaborators, supervisors or others with any type of conflicts of interest are excluded. Reviewers disclose competing interests before accepting and report new conflicts or recognition of an anonymised author promptly. Authors may suggest or request exclusion of reviewers with reasons, but the editor independently verifies and selects them.
Reviewers accept only assignments within their expertise and agreed availability. They provide respectful, specific, evidence-based comments, distinguish essential corrections from optional suggestions, and avoid discriminatory remarks and coercive citations. Manuscripts and correspondence remain confidential during and after review. Reviewer is prohibited to use AI for assessment and implement authors’ manuscript or any other confidential information in the process or after review. Reviewers must not exploit unpublished information of the reviewed manuscript. Involving a colleague for reviewing process requires prior editorial permission, conflict disclosure and confidentiality safeguards; a co-review counts as one report. Suspected misconduct is reported privately to the editor.
Assessment criteria and Reviewer Form
Assessment considers the research question, contribution, methods, analysis, evidence, interpretation, limitations, literature, reporting and ethics, as appropriate to the article type. Null or inconclusive findings are not grounds for rejection when the work is sound and relevant. Reviewers use the Pulso Científico Reviewer Form and explain their recommendation. Author-facing comments must be separated from confidential comments and must not reveal reviewer identities. Scores influence, but do not determine, decisions. Final decision is made by Editor in Chief on the bases of reviewers’ assessment, AI detection output and plagiarism check.
Reviewer Form - open or download: Reviewer Form. The current form is also supplied through the review assignment. Completed forms are returned to editorial office and they contact to the author with individual feedback.
Editorial decisions and revision
Reviewers give advice and editors make final decision. The handling editor assesses the evidence, report quality and author responses. The Editor-in-Chief issues the final decision and remains accountable for the process, except when recusal is required. Decisions are acceptance, minor revision, major revision or rejection. A revision request is not acceptance. Authors receive reasons and anonymised reports and must submit a revised manuscript with a point-by-point response for revision and explain detailed changes and any reasoned disagreement.
Minor changes may be checked by the editor; major scientific changes normally return for expert reassessment. Conflicting reports may require another independent reviewer; decisions are not a simple vote. Inadequate or compromised reports are excluded and replaced, ensuring two valid independent reports before acceptance. Unresolved integrity concerns may justify rejection before publication, including after acceptance, with an explanation and an opportunity to respond where appropriate.
If the manuscript gets one positive and one negative review, it is sent to the third independent reviewer.
Timeframes and communication
Editorial targets are: preliminary assessment within 7 calendar days; technical corrections within 7 days; external review within 10–21 days of accepting the assignment; an editorial decision within 3 working days after sufficient reports; author revision within 14 days for minor or 45 days for major revision; and editorial checking of minor revisions within 7 days. Proof corrections are normally returned within 7 days. The target for a first decision after external review is about 45 days from a complete submission; this is not a measured average or guarantee. If any review isn’t possible to fulfill in a timely manner the manuscript will be considered for the following issue.
Extensions may be agreed. Reviewer availability, further rounds and integrity inquiries may extend processing. Editors inform authors of significant delays and revised expectations. Authors may request withdrawal through the official editorial channel. Manuscript publication rescheduling never justify reducing review quality or guaranteeing acceptance.
Independence and special issues
Decisions depend on scholarly merit, scope and integrity, without discrimination or pressure from commercial, institutional or personal interests. Editors and board members cannot handle or decide on their own work. A non-conflicted editor manages their submissions with two independent external reviewers; an external editor is appointed if necessary. The published article states the independent handling arrangement.
Special issues, invited articles and conference-related submissions follow the same requirements. The Editor-in-Chief verifies and oversees guest editors and remains responsible for all content. Guest editors’ own submissions receive independent handling and may comprise no more than 25% of a special issue. Articles authored by editors, board members or reviewers must not exceed 25% of research papers in either of the two latest issues. If editor or reviewer assigns article in journal for publication. They don’t take part in editorial or reviewing process in this issue.
AI confidentiality and human responsibility
Generative AI must not assess manuscripts, generate substantive reviews or make editorial decisions. Confidential manuscripts, data and correspondence must not enter to any public or AI services. Limited language correction of a reviewer’s own completed comments requires prior editorial permission, confidentiality safeguards, human verification and disclosure of tool and purpose. Equivalent safeguards apply to editors. Editors retain responsibility for every decision.
Appeals records and policy maintenance
Authors may appeal through the journal’s official contact channel, identifying the manuscript, grounds and evidence. A non-conflicted editor uninvolved in the disputed decision, or an independent external adviser evaluates the appeal and communicates reasons. Conduct complaints are handled separately and without retaliation. Integrity concerns may require a pause, author explanation, independent advice or institutional referral; post-publication concerns follow the Code of Ethics and correction procedures.
The editorial office keeps restricted-access records of conflicts, invitations, reports, revisions and decisions under applicable privacy and retention rules. Articles display publication, submission and acceptance dates. The Editor-in-Chief maintains equivalent language versions, records adoption and revision dates, and ensures editorial training.















